[Howto] Rebase feature branches in Git/Github

Git-Icon-1788CUpdating a feature branch to the actual state of the upstream main branch can be troublesome. Here is a workflow that works – at least for me.

Developing with Git is amazing, due to the possibilities to work with feature branches, remote repositories and so on. However, at some point, after some hours of development, the base of a feature branch will be outdated and it makes sense to update it before a pull request is send upstream. This is best done via rebasing. Here is a short work flow for a typical feature branch rebase I often need when developing for example Ansible modules.

  1. First, checkout the main branch, here devel.
  2. Update the main branch from the upstream repository.
  3. Rebase the local copy of the main branch.
  4. Push it to the remote origin, most likely your personal fork of the Git repo.
  5. Check out the feature branch
  6. Rebase the feature branch to the main branch.
  7. Force push the new history to the remote feature branch, most likely again your personal fork of the Git repo.

In terms of code this means:

$ git checkout devel
$ git fetch upstream devel
$ git rebase upstream/devel
$ git push
$ git checkout feature_branch
$ git rebase origin/devel
$ git push -f

This looks rather clean and easy – but I have to admit it took me quite some errors and Git cherry picking to finally get what is needed and what actually works.

[Howto] Vagrant: libvirt, (Multi-)Multi-Machine, Ansible and Puppet

Jean Victor Balin - CubesVagrant is a tool to create and configure virtual development environments. As a wrapper around common virtual machine solutions it helps bringing up and disposing a virtual machine in a glimpse. I played around with it – and, well, got a bit carried away…

What all the fuzz is about… – Vagrant Basics

Simply said, Vagrant is nothing more than a wrapper around your average virtualization solution. While it was mainly developed for VirtualBox these days it also supports libvirt/kvm, Amazon, VMWare and others. The aim is to have one single description file to bring up and tear down an entire virtual machine with simple commands. That way each developer or tester can use the same description file and thus the same environment – Vagrant wants to fight the “works on my machine” excuse. Also, since bringing up and disposing images is a matter of seconds all testing and development can be done against clean environments.

Another big feature is that Vagrant seamlessly integrates with configuration management systems like Puppet, Chef, Ansible and others. Thus the deployment of the virtual development machines can be done with the same configuration scripts you use for your production environment.

The Vagrant VMs are always spawned from a base image, which is again derived from a so called “box”. There are many of these boxes freely available on the internet. Most of them have the same features: only basic packages installed plus Puppet, Chef and similar clients, a user vagrant with the password vagrant, sudo rights and an insecure ssh public key in .ssh/authorized_keys.

Why? – The motivation

The question quickly arises why anyone should use Vagrant. After all, virsh already is a proper abstraction layer for qemu and kvm and provides quite some functionality. The rest can be done manually or by helper scripts: bringing up a VM, installing configuration management, throwing machines away, bringing new ones up, etc.

However, Vagrant is much simpler than virsh, and also offers a simple but kind of sane configuration file for it. And its easier to use Vagrant which is continuously improved than developing and maintaining your own set of scripts.

There are of course other solutions – Docker is rather often mentioned in this regard. I have not really looked at Docker or other alternatives in detail, so I won’t do a comparison right now. Maybe I will find time in the future to really dive into Docker and then compare them – if possible at all.

Can we start now? – Basic usage

Vagrant was originally developed around VirtualBox. Since I am used to libvirt i decided to test Vagrant on libvirt. James has written an incredible helpful howto describing what to do and where users should be careful.

The general steps are on Fedora (and similar on other machines like Debian, etc.):

  • get a recent Vagrant rpm and install it
  • throw in some dependencies for later: libvirt-devel, libxslt-devel, libxml2-devel, virsh, qemu-img
  • call vagrant and install a plugin to convert VirtualBox images to libvirt ones: vagrant plugin install vagrant-mutate
  • get the first Vagrant box: vagrant box add precise32 http://files.vagrantup.com/precise32.box – the default example, it a VirtualBox image
  • transform it to a VMDK2 image, because Fedora’s qemu right now cannot handle VMDK3 images: wget https://raw.github.com/erik-smit/one-liners/master/qemu-img.vmdk3.hack.sh, chmod u+x qemu-img.vmdk3.hack.sh, ./qemu-img.vmdk3.hack.sh ~/.vagrant.d/boxes/precise32/virtualbox/box-disk1.vmdk
  • mutate the VirtualBox image to libvirt: vagrant mutate precise32 libvirt
  • initiate a Vagrant project: vagrant init precise32, as you see the Vagrant configuration file called Vagrantfile is created
  • launch your first Vagrant box: vagrant up

And you are done! You’ve created your first VM with Vagrant. You can get access via vagrant ssh:

$ vagrant ssh
Welcome to Ubuntu 12.04 LTS (GNU/Linux 3.2.0-23-generic-pae i686)

 * Documentation:  https://help.ubuntu.com/
Welcome to your Vagrant-built virtual machine.
Last login: Fri Sep 14 06:22:31 2012 from

The command drops to a normal shell on the machine as the user “vagrant”.

And now comes the beauty of vagrant: with a single vagrant destroy you can get rid of the entire VM including the wasted space. If you want to try it again: vagrant up, box goes up, vagrant destroy, box goes down. Box goes up, Box goes down. Box goes up, box goes down.

Each time all modifications to the VM are lost, thus you can ensure all your changes in configuration management and development work against a clean environment. And it only takes half a minute to bring up the machine!

By the way, before you get too experimental: your current working directory is exported as a NFS share. Thus exchanging files between the machines is rather easy. But it also means that you should not try rm -rf / on a Vagrant machine.

Got problems? – Troubleshooting

What, already? Well… In that case, launch virt-manager and look at the machine. After all, Vagrant is just a wrapper!

For example if DHCP failed or NFS timed out it might be that there are problems with the firewall rules of the host machine. The way to allow the proper connections for recent Fedora versions is explained in Vagrant issue #2447. Basically, the Vagrant libvirt network bridge should be assigned to the internal zone, and services like NFS, DHCP, mountd and rpc for both TCP and UDP should be added there.

Also, if the request for the user password comes up all the time to secure only authorized access to the virtual machine management, PolicyKit rules can permanently provide proper rights. James’ blog post mentioned above explains the details.

And in case each machine gets two adapters with two IP addresses… well, that happened to me as well, and so far I have no solution. I am happy for any help regarding that topic.

Storage! – Where to put the images and boxes

Running virtual machines eats your storage. Usually, the boxes are managed in ~/.vagrant.d/boxes, while the actual VM templates and the machines themselves are stored in the default storage of the default virtual machine provider. In this case that is the default storage of libvirt.

It makes sense to dedicate an extra storage pool like an extra partition to Vagrant. That can be achieved by creating a storage pool in libvirt and telling Vagrant in the Vagrantfile about it. The “provider” section is the right place for that:

# Provider-specific configuration
config.vm.provider :libvirt do |libvirt|
    libvirt.driver = "qemu"
    libvirt.connect_via_ssh = false
    libvirt.storage_pool_name = "vm-images"

Providers are Vagrants name for virtual environments like VirtualBox, libvirt and so on. In this example the provider libvirt is ensured in case other providers are installed on the host as well. Also , the storage pool name is given, “vm-images”.

We want more! – Getting other boxes

In the above example an Ubuntu Precise machine was used. But it might rather well be that someone would like to use other operating systems or versions as a base. Quite some are listed at vagrantbox.es. Also, the Puppet project provides some useful boxes, even “clean” ones without any further additions installed.

However, using boxes from others is of course a security risk. But there is a way to build boxes yourself. I found James’ Makefile very handy: It uses virt-builder from the libguestfs project to build a CentOS 6 machine. Of course, using images from libguestfs only reduces your security risk, best would be to build your own images from scratch.

I built my CentOS 6 images using the above mentioned Makefile with two smaller adjustments to avoid problems with SSH fingerprints an for a better Ansible integration.

One, one-two, one-two-three! – Multi machines

Vagrant makes fun already – but things get more interesting with the possibility to start more than one machine. The Vagrant Documentation about multi-machines shows how further machines can be added – and named – in the Vagrantfile:

  config.vm.define "staging" do |staging|
    staging.vm.network private_network, ip: ""

  config.vm.define "prod" do |prod|
    prod.vm.network private_network, ip: ""

In this example two machines are now available: one named “staging” and one called “prod”, both with different IP addresses. Now all the Vagrant commands like up and ssh need the name of the machine to know on which machine they should act: vagrant up staging, vagrant ssh staging and vagrant destroy staging.

If no machine name is given, the task like up and destroy is run on all machine at the same time, in parallel. That can lead to problems like frozen machines, for unknown reasons. In such cases a workaround is to start the machines with the option --no-parallel.

Do you YAML? – Defining machines in external files

Being excited by the simplicity of Vagrant I got playful – and decided that specifying machines in the Vagrantfile is not very handy. Also, since I have no idea of Ruby and I am bound to make errors when I have to alter the file often. Thus I decided to specify machines in a YAML file, including name and IP. I picked YAML because I know it from Hiera/Puppet, Ansible and others. The file looks like the following:

- name: prod
  environment: prod
- name: staging
  environment: staging

This must be read into Vagrant – and luckily the entire script to read in these YAML data can be placed in the Vagrantfile itself:

  require 'yaml'
  servers = YAML.load_file('servers.yaml')

  servers.each do |servers|
      config.vm.define servers["name"] do |serv|
          serv.vm.network "private_network", ip: servers["ip"]

That’s it already. Now Vagrant can run as many machines as are specified in the YAML file.

Multi multi multi – Specifying multi-machines with different boxes

But that wasn’t enough – I work in two worlds, Debian/Ubuntu and Fedora/CentOS, and thus needed to be able to spawn VMs of CentOS and Ubuntu images. Thus I added the box name to the YAML file: “centos64” is the base box for a recent CentOS, and “saucy64” the base box for the last Ubuntu release.

- name: cstaging
  box: centos64
- name: ustaging
  box: saucy64

The names need to be different so that Vagrant can differentiate between the machines. In the above outlined example the names are prefixed with “u” for the Ubuntu machines and “c” for the CentOS machines.

The sourc ecode to read in the details in the Vagrantfile are:

  servers.each do |servers|
      config.vm.define servers["name"] do |serv|
          serv.vm.box = servers["box"]
          serv.vm.network "private_network", ip: servers["ip"]

Do what I want! – Configuration management

As mentioned in the beginning, the real strength of Vagrant shines when it comes to integrating configuration management: Imagine a setup where all the developers work on the main Gits of the configuration management and the application only. And when they want to see if their changes work, they just fire up Vagrant: upon vagrant up development a new VM is deployed, all configurations and the application code from the stage “development” are pulled and installed automatically, and the developer just checks if everything is alright. Afterwards, the developer destroys the VM, and pushes the just tested changes to the staging repo.

To make that come true we need to integrate configuration management with Vagrant. By the way: Vagrant speaks about “provisioning” here not the best naming, but you got to live with it. Anyway, as mentioned there are multiple was to integrate configuration management. Puppet alone can be run by puppet apply or in terms of a real Puppet client, and the multiple configuration management systems can be even combined and run after each other. Here I will only shed some light on integrating either Ansible or Puppet Apply.

The decision which machine is to be managed by which solution will – of course – be done in the YAML file:

- name: cclean
  box: centos64
  prov: ansible
  environment: staging
- name: uclean
  box: saucy64
  prov: puppet
  environment: common

The CentOS machines will be managed by Ansible, the Ubuntu ones by Puppet. Also, please note that additional variables for stages are defined which might come in handy later on.

Simple and fast – integrating Ansible

I like Ansible. It’s really fast and easy to deploy. The same is true for its integration with Vagrant:

  servers.each do |servers|
      config.vm.define servers["name"] do |serv|
          serv.vm.box = servers["box"]
          serv.vm.network "private_network", ip: servers["ip"]
          if servers["prov"] == "ansible"
              serv.vm.provision "ansible" do |ansible|
                  ansible.playbook = "ansible/playbook.yaml"

A subdirectory called “ansible” contains the playbook which is needed by Ansible. And, well, that’s it. The Vagrant Ansible documentation covers some more options like additional variables which can set. These come in handy when you need to differentiate between various environments like staging and production.

But in general, you can now write your playbook as you like and see how Ansible works its way. It is automatically launched after the NFS share was made ready.

Big and heavy – Puppet

Compared to Ansible, Puppet is rather heavy, and not that quick&dirty. Thus, the integration with Vagrant is a bit more difficult. But in general it is what anyone would expect of a Puppet server: a Hiera configuration, a modules directory and a basic Puppet manifest file to start with. The integration with Vagrant is done entirely in the Vagrantfile, and is shown below together with the the already above mentioned configuration:

  servers.each do |servers|
      config.vm.define servers["name"] do |serv|
          serv.vm.box = servers["box"]
          serv.vm.network "private_network", ip: servers["ip"]
          if servers["prov"] == "ansible"
              serv.vm.provision "ansible" do |ansible|
                  ansible.playbook = "ansible/playbook.yaml"
          elsif servers["prov"] == "puppet"
              serv.vm.provision :puppet do |puppet|
                  puppet.manifest_file  = "site.pp"
                  puppet.manifests_path = "puppet/manifests"
                  puppet.module_path = "puppet/modules"
                  puppet.hiera_config_path = "puppet/hiera.yaml"
                  puppet.working_directory = "/vagrant/puppet"
                  puppet.facter = { 
                      "environment" => servers["environment"]

In the example above an environment variable is provided to the Puppet Apply routine in form of a facter variable. Also, please note that a working directory has to be given so that all necessary files like the hieradata store can be found by Puppet. The rest is, however, pure Puppet: getting proper modules, setting up a well designed hierarchy with Hiera, etc.

Sooo…. What now? – Conclusion

Well… in the beginning I just wanted to understand what Vagrant exactly does and how and if it can help me. After getting this far I can say it will help me a lot in the future: creating and dumping virtual machines was never so quick and easy.

With the option of integrating configuration provisioning methods it can really change the way people develop code in business environments like for customers at my work at credativ. Often enough customers are simply too busy to bring up a VM because it takes too much time and is too tedious even with predefined scripts. They end up developing on their own machine, and later on run into problems with the further development. At such points Vagrant’s ease and simplicity can be incredible helpful to test configuration management recipes or development code. It could greatly ease the pain of providing an automated QA workflow where the QA testers get their own disposable VMs which are automatically brought up with the current testing stage.

But even for smaller setups like “personal” development Vagrant can really make things easier: as mentioned in the beginning, many people use virtualization in ways more or less similar to Vagrant. But keeping together personal scripts to bring up and destroy machines is a tedious work. Vagrant makes it quicker, simpler, and thus more reliable. Only for one-time tasks where for example I would need to create an entire new box in Vagrant I might still use virt-manager.

Of course, some bits are still missing. For example the provisioning done by YAML file could be improved so that Ansible, Puppet and all the others could share a single server configuration base with Vagrant. And as mentioned above, a comparison with other solutions would be nice as well.

But so far Vagrant has proven itself: Whenever I need to repeatedly test some configuration or integration I will use Vagrant. And I am already looking forward to all the shiny things which I can test now just a bit easier.

Wall-Skills.com Advent calender launched – one 1-pager each day

Simple Workflow diagramIt happened: we launched the wall-skills.com Advent calendar, featuring one 1-pager every day to hang up on your office walls. Daily learning and improving your skills just got easier.

As announced a couple of weeks ago Wall-Skills.com launched its Advent calendar today. For the ext 24 days we will release one new 1-pager each day featuring information worth reading and learning about agile software development, IT project management and sometimes even self improvement tips for office workers.

Get the 1-pagers, hang them upon your office and toilet walls, and share knowledge which you think should be shared among your colleagues and team members. Subscribe to the RSS feed and make sure you don’t miss any Advent calendar post.

Today’s feature is about the Agile principles:

I’d like to thanks to Corinna from finding-marbles.com for her awesome dedication to the project, her design and work – and also for coming up with the idea to transform my 1-pagers into an actual project.

If you have interesting Ideas you’d like to share with the Wall-Skills community, let us know. The Advent calendar is almost filled by now, but there we plan to release more 1-pagers in the weeks after.

Wall-Skills – learning with 1-pagers, and an Advent Calender

Simple Workflow diagramA couple of weeks ago I introduced Learning on the Toilet here at this blog as well as at my regular Agile Meetup. It was well received, and fellow agile developer Corinna convinced me to team up and launch a dedicated project, which we called: wall-skills.com!

The idea for wall-skills.com is based upon Learning on the toilet (#LotT), which is again based upon Google’s Testing on the Toilet: it means hanging up 1-pagers on walls in places like toilets, on refrigerators and so on for people to read during their “leisure” time. The idea is to bring up information worth reading which can be summarized on one single page to improve the skills of the members of your company. Even if you read all the books about one topic, sometimes an additional tip or some prodding is just what you need. And if it’s hanging on a wall in a place where when you see it, you can’t ignore it.

The idea of Learning on the Toilet was well received when I presented the idea at my regulars Agile Meetup, I got a lot of constructive feedback. And Corinna (finding-marbles.com) brought up the idea to team up and create a project page dedicated to collect and spread such 1-pagers. Thus we met, found a name – hanging 1-pagers on “walls” to improve “skills”, aren’t we brilliant 😉 – and launched a project page: wall-skills.com was born!

So in the future we will collect 1-page PDFs or images on Agile, Lean, development, devOps, system administration, Scrum and Kanban at wall-skills.com – ready for you to print out.

Right now we have published two sample posts to give you an idea what to expect. To kick off the project page and the entire collection we will present more 1-pagers in form of an Advent Calendar, publishing a new 1-pager each day of December until the 24th. So stay tuned – and subscribe to our RSS feed =)

Currently we’ve got ideas for most of the 24 slots, but some slots are still open and a greater diversity is always more interesting. Also, we will need more information for the future. If you got great, suitable content in your blog, tell us! Contact us on Twitter, via email, via this blog, whatever. If you are quick (that means 25th of November) your content might be included with the Advent Calendar, including a short paragraph about you and your blog.

And of course, please feel free to tell us what you think of the project, of the 1-pagers, and so on.